Tuesday, August 3, 2010

David Warren's errors continue

Still no corrections for these errors in a David Warren article a couple weeks ago. The Ottawa Citizen won’t even run a letter, preferring to let IVF offspring believe their fathers are not really their fathers, and that they are actually the “abnormal” children of anonymous sperm donors. The Citizen now seems very reluctant to provide corrections for Warren’s falsehoods – and even Letters to the Editor in response to his articles have dropped from about 260 per year in 2003 to about 20.

Given carte blanche, it’s not surprising that the problems continue. In “On being skeptically attentive”, July 31, Warren claims there’s no problem with the BP oil spill, offering up some figures:

“As that Time article…now report(s), the fish and shrimp of the Gulf coast are still testing clean… Assessment teams have found only 350 acres of oiled marshes along the coast. (Compare: 150,000 acres of wetlands lost annually, along the same coast, to natural erosive forces.) Surface oil has all but disappeared, already, by organic breakdown.”

But on coastal wetland loss, the Time article in fact reads:

“Assessment teams have found only about 350 acres of oiled marshes, when Louisiana was already losing about 15,000 acres of wetlands every year”.

That number is confirmed by Audubon: “every year the state loses more than 15,000 acres of protective, productive coastal wetlands.”

And again: About 15,000 acres of wetlands in coastal Louisiana are being converted to open water each year.”

Or, The wetlands are disappearing at a rate of about 15,000 acres per year.”

In addition to inflating the acres of lost wetlands from 15,000 to 150,000, Warren also claims it is due to “natural erosive forces”. But the Times article he refers to states otherwise: “much of the erosion has been caused by the re-engineering of the Mississippi River — which no longer deposits much sediment at the bottom of its Delta — quite a bit has been caused by the oil and gas industry, which gouged 8,000 miles of canals and pipelines through coastal wetlands”. Time describes these human impacts as a “cancer”.

Other sources concur: “much of it (erosion) is due to human activity. U.S. Geological Survey maps indicate that about 36 percent of the loss is due to the dredging of canals through the wetlands by the oil industry”. And “erosion began in earnest in 1927, when the US Army Corps of Engineers built levees along the Mississippi River... Also, the oil and gas industries have used the area for more than 8,000 miles of canals and pipelines to add to the losses…”

And of course, as everyone knows, oil in the Gulf has been broken up by the massive and unprecedented use of chemical dispersants, not “organic breakdown” as Warren claims.

Gamely, Warren continues: “One could go into great detail on the farce of misrepresenting the scale of the BP disaster. The nonsense is now being quietly corrected, to a much smaller audience than the one that absorbed the lies.”

“Farce” and “lies” indeed. Given Warren’s uncorrected article on IVF a few weeks ago, we’ll wait and see if he will “quietly correct” this time. Don’t bet on it.


  1. Good job - keep after the clown!

  2. It's a dirty job, but someone's got to do it. And yet, after so many retractions (and an even larger number of uncorrected errors brought to their attention), not a single thank you from Mr. Warren or the Ottawa Citizen! It almost makes you think they want to provide false information to readers.